9. The American Pie Girls
Oh, how the geeks of the world would have loved Alyson Hannigan to be among the list, but the How I Met Your Mother actress kept her clothes on, despite what may have happened at band camp. Less than two months after the original movie about four guys on a quest to lose their virginity came out in theaters, Shannon Elizabeth, who played sexy foreign exchange student Nadia, took it all off for Playboy in their August 1999 issue. It may have been a case of “strike when the iron is hot” but aside from cameos in the franchise’s sequels and a string of straight-to-video horror movies, this bombshell has mostly been seen on ESPN in her new role as real-life poker player. Her blonde co-star, Tara Reid, has recently resurfaced thanks to the campy Sharknado movies, but has spent most of her post-Pie years relegated to small projects and celebrity reality shows. Reid’s Jan./Feb 2010 pictorial left little to the imagination of guys who had fallen in love with her 11 years earlier.
Discussion about this post