The 12 hottest American Idol contestants (With Pics)

3. Pia Toscano

Pia Toscano finished in ninth place in season ten ofAmerican Idol. Up until that point she was considered a favorite, and judges Jennifer Lopez, Randy Jackson, and Steven Tyler were all upset about her being eliminated too soon. Before American Idol, Pia worked as a make-up artist and as a wedding singer. Even with her amazing talent and beauty, Toscano has had a tough time getting her career up and running. She signed with Interscope Records and released one single with modest success. Toscano worked as a background singer for judge/advocate Jennifer Lopez in 2014 and has been trying to find success with a series of collaborations with other artists.