Top 20 most overrated NFL players of all time (With Pictures)

6. Peyton Manning

This is coming from somebody who has admittedly been a massive fan of Peyton Manning since his days in college. Nobody, not even Manning’s biggest admirers, can pretend that the all-time great who will deservedly be inducted into the Hall of Fame has not been outdone by contemporary Tom Bradywhen it has mattered most. Manning is going to possess a ton of records when he does step away from the playing field, and he very well may be the best regular season quarterback of all time. In a one-and-done playoff game, however, you’d be wise to take a different option.