Top 20 most overrated NFL players of all time (With Pictures)

13. Joe Theismann

Joe Theismann deserves all of the praise that he has received for that stellar run that ended with the Washington Redskins quarterback hoisting a Most Valuable Player trophy. His presence during football television broadcasts have made him a known figure for fans who did not watch him play, and thus some of those individuals do not realize that Theismann was largely an OK passer for the bulk of his career. Those who would disagree with Theismann making the list must realize that there are plenty of good reasons to explain why he is not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.